top of page

Ice Cream Flavors

Guernsey Farms Dairy is a third-generation family owned company.  With 69 flavors to choose from, there will definitely be something for everyone!  We serve only the best!

Birthday Cake

Yellow cake batter & chocolate fudge swirled through vanilla ice cream and sprinkled throughout with chocolate cake pieces & rainbow sprinkles.

Allergens:  Milk, Wheat, Soy, Eggs

Black Cherry

Fresh sweet black cherries in smooth cherry ice cream.

Allergens: Milk          *Gluten Free*

Blue Moon

Fruity flavors in a blue colored ice cream.

Allergens: Milk          *Gluten Free*

Butter Pecan

Fresh roasted pecans swirled through a rich butter ice cream – rated the country’s best by People magazine.

Allergens:  Milk, Tree Nuts         

Butterscotch Fudge

Butterscotch fudge swirled through vanilla ice cream.

Allergens:  Milk          *Gluten Free*

Chocolate

The Midwest’s best chocolate ice cream – made with cocoa and fresh cream.

Allergens: Milk        *Gluten Free*

Chocolate Chip

Rich chocolate chips mixed throughout creamy vanilla ice cream.

Allergens: Milk, Soy          *Gluten Free*

Ch. Chip Cookie Dough

Chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough in smooth cookie dough ice cream.

Allergens:  Milk, Wheat, Soy

Chocolate Chunky Chocolate

Chunks of delicious chocolate mixed in rich chocolate ice cream.

Allergens:  Milk, Soy          *Gluten Free*

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Peanut butter swirled through chocolate ice cream.

Allergens: Milk & Peanuts          *Gluten Free*

Coffee

Bold coffee flavors blended with rich ice cream.

Allergens: Milk          *Gluten Free*

Coffee Mocha Chip

Rich mocha fudge and dark chocolate flakes swirled through bold coffee ice cream.

Allergens:  Milk & Soy          *Gluten Free*

Cookies N' Cream

Chunks of dark chocolate cookies in vanilla ice cream.

Allergens:  Milk, Wheat, Soy

French Vanilla

Thick egg custard mixed with our creamy vanilla ice cream.

Allergens: Milk & Eggs          *Gluten Free*

Fudge Whip

Thick chocolate fudge swirled through creamy vanilla ice cream.

Allergens: Milk & Soy          *Gluten Free*

Mackinac Island Fudge

Rich dark chocolate fudge swirled in creamy vanilla ice cream with chocolate fudge pieces.

Allergens:  Milk & Soy          *Gluten Free*

Mackinac Is. P.B. Fudge 

Creamy peanut butter ice cream swirled with thick fudge and peanut butter truffles.

Allergens:  Milk, Peanuts, Soy          *Gluten Free*

McGuire's Irish Mint

Dark chocolate mint cups and rivers of thick fudge in smooth mint ice cream.

Allergens: Milk & Soy          *Gluten Free*

Midnight Train To Traverse

Michigan sweet cherries in decadent chocolate ice cream with rich chicory coffee flavors.

Allergens: Milk          *Gluten Free*

Mint Chocolate Chip

Cool mint ice cream sprinkled with bits of rich chocolate chips.

Allergens:  Milk & Soy          *Gluten Free*

Moose Tracks

Vanilla ice cream with peanut butter cups swirled with thick chocolate fudge.

Allergens:  Milk, Peanuts, Soy          *Gluten Free*

Old Fashioned Strawberry

Creamy strawberry ice cream mixed with real strawberries.

Allergens: Milk          *Gluten Free*

Peppermint Stick

Red and green peppermint candy in mint ice cream.

Allergens: Milk & Soy         *Gluten Free*

Pistachio

Pistachios swirled in a fruit based ice cream.

Allergens:  Milk & Tree Nuts          *Gluten Free*

Praline Pecan

Caramel fudge and candied pecans in praline ice cream.

Allergens:  Milk, Tree Nuts          *Gluten Free*

Sea Salt Turtle Swirl

Toffee ice cream with a smooth salty caramel ribbon and a blend of rich caramel turtle.

Allergens: Milk & Soy          *Gluten Free*

Swiss Chocolate Almond

Rich milk chocolate ice cream mixed with almond slices.

Allergens: Milk & Tree Nuts          *Gluten Free*

Tilt-A-Swirl

Michigan raspberry ripples and rich Mackinac Island fudge chunks in a creamy white chocolate ice cream.

Allergens:  Milk & Soy          *Gluten Free*

Wolverine Tracks

Rich chocolate ice cream, marshmallow swirl, fudge cup and a sandwich cookie.

Allergens:  Milk, Wheat, Soy

White Russian Latte

An elegant white chocolate coffee background mingling with bold dark chocolate fudge pieces.

Allergens: Milk & Soy          *Gluten Free*

Superman

Mixed fruit ice cream with marshmallow ribbons and strawberries.

Allergens: Milk          *Gluten Free*

Strawberry Cheesecake

Luscious cheesecake base with strawberry rippled throughout.

Allergens:  Milk          *Gluten Free*

Snickers

Caramel and Snicker chips swirled through vanilla ice cream.

Allergens:  Milk, Peanut, Soy, Eggs          *Gluten Free*

Pride-N-Joy

A coconut flavored ice cream surrounded by chocolate covered almonds and milk chocolate flakes.

Allergens:  Milk, Tree Nuts, Soy          *Gluten Free*

Peanut Butter Paradise

Vanilla ice cream loaded with chocolate peanut butter cups and trails of creamy peanut butter.

Allegens:  Milk, Peanuts, Soy          *Gluten Free*

Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Batter

Peanut butter ice cream swirled with buckeye peanut butter cups with brownie and cookie dough pieces.

Allergens:  Milk, Peanuts, Wheat, Soy, Eggs

Orange Pineapple

A delectable blend of oranges and pineapples make this a seasonal classic!

Allergens:  Milk          *Gluten Free*

Michigan Two Way

Dark chocolate fudge swirled through chocolate ice cream loaded with chocolate fudge cups and premium broken cookie pieces.

Allergens:  Milk, Wheat, Soy

Maple Walnut

An East coast favorite! A rich maple ice cream chock full of large English walnuts.

Allergens:  Milk, Tree Nuts          *Gluten Free*

Mackinac Island Lilac

Aromatic spring lilac complemented by our rich, award winning ice cream.

Allergens:  Milk, Eggs          *Gluten Free*

Lemon Custard

Creamy lemon custard ice cream.

Allergens:  Milk, Eggs          *Gluten Free*

Lavender Honey

The essence of pure Michigan lavender personified in rich Guernsey ice cream with a hint of nourishing honey.

Allergens:  Milk          *Gluten Free*

Grandpa's Blueberry Way

A perfect blend of blueberries & pomegranates rippled through blueberry ice cream surrounded by rich dark chocolate flakes.

Allergens:  Milk, Soy          *Gluten Free*

Fudge Cookie Hurricane

Chunks of dark chocolate cookie and thick fudge in a creamy vanilla ice cream.

Allergens:  Milk, Wheat, Soy

Double Dark Sea Salt

A delicious double dark chocolate ice cream loaded with sea salt truffles and ripples of sea salt caramel.

Allergens:  Milk, Soy          *Gluten Free*

Detroit Grand Slam

A rich caramel coffee espresso base and a sea salt caramel swirl mixed with coffee espresso chocolate flakes.

Allergens:  Milk, Soy          *Gluten Free*

Dave's Sweet Tooth Toffee Tornado

Toffee flavored ice cream with chunks of milk chocolate toffee from our friends at Dave’s Sweet Tooth.

Allergens:  Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts

Creme De Novi

Crème de mint ice cream laced with rich chocolate flakes.

Allergens:  Milk, Soy          *Gluten Free*

Cotton Candy

A spot on pink cotton candy base immersed in a blue cotton candy swirl and a melt in your mouth multi colored flake. For your inner child and other kids too.

allergens:  Milk, Soy          *Gluten Free*

Cookie Monster

Dark blue moon flavored ice cream stuffed full of broken cookie chunks and cookie dough pieces.

Allergens:  Milk, Wheat, Soy

Cinnamon Roll

The warm comfort of a fresh baked cinnamon roll captured in our award winning ice cream. A savory cinnamon base, heavenly honey bun variegate and a top notch pecan. A must try!

Allergens:  Milk, Tree Nuts, Soy          *Gluten Free*

Chocolate Marshmallow

A marshmallow ribbon swirled through chocolate ice cream.

Allergens:  Milk          *Gluten Free*

Chocolate Malt Chip

Melt in your mouth broken whoppers surrounded by a smooth chocolate syrup mix.

Allergens:  Milk, Wheat, Soy

Chocolate Fudge Brownie

Brownie pieces and chocolate fudge swirled through chocolate ice cream.

Allergens:  Milk, Wheat, Soy, Egg

Chocolate Covered Strawberry

Real strawberry chunks in a strawberry ice cream covered with ripples of dark chocolate fudge.

Allergens:  Milk, Soy          *Gluten Free*

Cherry Amaretto

Kodiak fudge rolling through amaretto ice cream fields bursting with chocolate cherry cups.

Allergens:  Milk, Soy          *Gluten Free*

Caramel Caribou

Toffee ice cream rippled with thick golden caramel and sprinkled throughout with chocolate caramel cups.

Allergens:  Milk, Soy           *Gluten Free*

Bumpy Cake

Chocolate fudge cake pieces and buttercream ice cream swirled with chocolate ganache.

Allergens:  Milk, Wheat, Soy

Bear Claw

Dark chocolate ice cream filled with chocolate coated cashews and swirled with luscious thick golden caramel.

Allergens:  Milk, Tree Nuts, Soy          *Gluten Free*

Orange Sherbet

Our delicious orange flavored sherbet is sure to satisfy.

Allergens:  Milk           *Gluten Free*

Raspberry Sherbet

Cool and refreshing raspberry flavored sherbet.

Allergens:  Milk          *Gluten Free*

Veg-O-Licious Black Cherry

100% vegan oat based black cherry frozen dessert.

Allergens:  None          *Gluten Free*

Veg-O-Licious Butter Pecan

100% vegan oat based butter pecan frozen dessert.

Allergens:  Tree Nuts          *Gluten Free*

Butter Pecan (No Sugar Added)

Our award winning butter pecan ice cream with no added sugar.

Allergens:  Milk, Tree Nuts          *Gluten Free*

Vanilla (No Sugar Added)

Rich, classic vanilla ice cream with no added sugar.

Allergens:  Milk          *Gluten Free*

Vanilla

The finest vanilla beans make this time honored classic a best seller. Perfection!

Allergens:  Milk          *Gluten Free*

Southern Butter Pecan

A southern spin on our award winning classic! Buttery pecans in our sweet, southern base. Y’all will love it!

Allergens:  Milk & Pecans  

*Gluten Free*

southern butter pecan.jpg
peanut butter cookies and cream.jpg

Peanut Butter Cookies & Cream

A savory peanut butter ice cream with generous amounts of cookies complemented by an icing swirl.

Allergens:  Milk, Wheat, Soy, Peanuts

Veg o Licious Coconut Blueberry

100% vegan oat based! A divine blueberry swirl bursting through scrumptious coconut

Allergens:  Coconut          *Gluten Free*

veg o licious coconut blueberry.jpg

Novelty Ice Cream

We carry many popular Novelty flavors.  Here are some of our best selling choices!

Strawberry Eclair

Chocolate Eclair

Cookies 'N Creme Eclair

Bomb Pop

M & M Ice Cream Cookie

bottom of page